On a Muggy Night in Mumbai by Mahesh Dattani: a critique of a homophobic Indian society

On a Muggy Night in Mumbai

Mahesh Dattani

(A critique of a homophobic Indian society)

Q. Critically discuss Mahesh Dattani’s On a Muggy Night in Mumbai as “a critique of a homophobic Indian society”.

Answer: Mahesh Dattani’s play "On a Muggy Night in Mumbai" is a powerful critique of a homophobic Indian society. The play explores the issue of homosexuality, which is still considered taboo in many parts of India, and sheds light on the societal pressures and discrimination faced by members of the LGBTQ+ community.

The play centers around the relationship between two men, Bishan and Raghu, who are in love with each other but are unable to express their feelings openly due to the social stigma attached to homosexuality. Bishan, a successful businessman, is married and has a son, but he is deeply unhappy and conflicted about his sexuality. Raghu, on the other hand, is a struggling actor who is more comfortable with his homosexuality and is willing to take risks to be with the person he loves.

Dattani's play exposes the hypocrisy of Indian society, which is quick to condemn homosexuality but turns a blind eye to other forms of sexual deviance such as extramarital affairs, prostitution, and sexual harassment. The play shows how the societal pressure to conform to heterosexual norms and expectations can lead to individuals suppressing their true identities and desires, which in turn can lead to emotional and psychological distress.

Through the character of Bishan, Dattani also critiques the institution of marriage in India, which is often used as a tool for social conformity rather than a genuine expression of love and commitment. Bishan's marriage is portrayed as a loveless and oppressive arrangement, which he is unable to escape due to societal expectations.

Moreover, the play also highlights the intersectionality of discrimination faced by members of the LGBTQ+ community in India. The characters of Bishan and Raghu are both from marginalized backgrounds - Bishan is a Dalit (formerly known as untouchable) while Raghu is from a lower socio-economic class. This adds another layer of complexity to their struggles as they face not only discrimination based on their sexuality but also discrimination based on their caste and class.

Dattani's play also explores the theme of power dynamics in relationships. Bishan, being the older and financially successful partner, holds a certain power over Raghu. This power dynamic is portrayed as unhealthy and exploitative, leading to emotional turmoil for both characters.

Still, the play raises questions about the role of the media in shaping societal attitudes towards homosexuality. The character of the journalist who approaches Bishan and Raghu for an interview is shown to be insensitive and exploitative, using their story for sensationalist purposes rather than to promote understanding and acceptance.

Furthermore, the play highlights the role of religion in perpetuating homophobia and intolerance towards the LGBTQ+community in India. The character of Bishan's mother, who is deeply religious, is shown to be intolerant and dismissive of homosexuality, citing religious teachings as justification for her bigotry.

In brief, Mahesh Dattani’s "On a Muggy Night in Mumbai" is a powerful critique of a homophobic Indian society that continues to stigmatize and discriminate against members of the LGBTQ+community. The play is an important work of literature that challenges societal norms and prejudices. Through its nuanced portrayal of complex characters and their struggles, the play invites its audience to reflect on their own attitudes towards homosexuality and the LGBTQ+ community, and encourages them to work towards creating a more inclusive and accepting society. The play, thus, sheds light on the emotional and psychological toll of living in a society that denies individuals the right to love and express themselves freely.

*****

👉 'Kanthapura by Raja Rao: Use of myths in the novel

👉 ''Harvest' by Jim Crace: Projection of a dystopian future

👉 'On a Muggy Night in Mumbai by Mahesh Dattani

👉 'Judith Butler's book, Gender Trouble: Concept of the Performativity of Gender

👉 'The Second Sex: Simone de Beauvoir’s view on Patriarchy and Feminism

👉 'Gender and Literature: Body has been a Contested Site in Gender Studies

👉 'The Pluralities of Masculinities with appropriate examples:Gender and Literature

👉 'Walt Whitman’s celebration to the ‘self’ and the ‘society’ in his poems

👉 'Moll Flanders as a Realistic Novel

👉 'The School for Scandal as a Restoration Comedy or‘Comedy of Manners’

👉 'The Scarlet Letter' by Nathaniel Hawthorne - Significance of the Title