Freud's concept of 'melancholia' in his essay, Mourning and Melancholia

Mourning and Melancholia

Sigmund Freud

(Freud's concept of 'melancholia')

Q. "Melancholia, therefore, borrows some of its features from mourning and the others from the process of regression from narcissistic object-choice to narcissism." Explain Freud's concept of 'melancholia' in the light of the above remark

Answer: In Freud's psychoanalytic theory, melancholia is a type of depression that is characterized by a profound sense of loss and mourning. In his essay "Mourning and Melancholia," Freud argues that melancholia is closely related to mourning, but with some significant differences.

According to Freud, both mourning and melancholia involve a sense of loss, but in mourning, the loss is related to a specific person or object, while in melancholia, the loss is more generalized and abstract. In melancholia, the person experiences a sense of loss without knowing what has been lost, leading to a feeling of emptiness and despair.

Freud also argues that in melancholia, the person experiences a regression from a more mature state of object-choice to a more narcissistic state. Object-choice refers to the process by which a person forms attachments to other people or objects. In melancholia, the person regresses to a state of self-absorption, where they become preoccupied with their own internal state and lose touch with the external world.

Freud sees melancholia as a complex process that involves both mourning and narcissistic regression. The person experiences a sense of loss but is unable to identify what has been lost, leading to feelings of emptiness and self-absorption. The concept of melancholia reflects Freud's belief that psychological disorders are not simply the result of biological or environmental factors but are shaped by complex unconscious processes.

In addition to the features mentioned in the previous response, Freud's concept of melancholia also includes the idea of ambivalence. According to Freud, the person experiencing melancholia has an ambivalent attitude towards the lost object or person, which can include both love and hate. This ambivalence can lead to feelings of guilt and self-punishment, which further contribute to the sense of despair and hopelessness.

Freud also notes that in melancholia, the person can have a distorted perception of reality. They may feel that they are worthless or that the world is empty and meaningless. This distorted perception can result from the person's internal conflicts and their inability to reconcile their conflicting feelings towards the lost object or person.

Another important aspect of Freud's concept of melancholia is the role of identification. In mourning, the person gradually disengages from the lost object and forms new attachments. In melancholia, however, the person identifies with the lost object, taking on its characteristics and becoming one with it. This identification can be a way for the person to hold onto the lost object, but it can also contribute to their sense of emptiness and loss.

Overall, Freud's concept of melancholia emphasizes the complex and often unconscious processes involved in depression and mourning. It highlights the importance of understanding the individual's internal conflicts and psychological processes in the development and treatment of psychological disorders.

*****

👉 'Freud's concept of 'melancholia' in his essay, Mourning and Melancholia

👉 'Collective Trauma and its distinctive features: M.A. English (4th Semester)

👉 'Trauma's Role in Memory: relationship between trauma and memory

👉 'Clear Light of Day by Anita Desai: Images of ‘light’

👉 'Kanthapura by Raja Rao: Use of myths in the novel

👉 ''Harvest' by Jim Crace: Projection of a dystopian future

👉 'On a Muggy Night in Mumbai by Mahesh Dattani

👉 'Judith Butler's book, Gender Trouble: Concept of the Performativity of Gender

👉 'The Second Sex: Simone de Beauvoir’s view on Patriarchy and Feminism

👉 'Gender and Literature: Body has been a Contested Site in Gender Studies

👉 'The Pluralities of Masculinities with appropriate examples:Gender and Literature