Politics and the English Language by George Orwell | 'political writing is bad writing'

Politics and the English Language by George Orwell | 'political writing is bad writing'

Q. Why does Orwell state that ‘political writing is bad writing’? Elucidate with reference to the essay ‘Politics and the English Language’.

Answer: "Politics and the English Language" is a famous essay written by George Orwell, first published in 1946. In this essay, Orwell discusses the relationship between political discourse and the English language. He criticizes the degradation of language and argues that the use of vague, pretentious, and manipulative language in political writing and speech is not only a symptom but also a cause of intellectual and political decay.

George Orwell in his essay "Politics and the English Language" explores the idea that political writing often tends to be characterized by bad or subpar writing. He argues that there are several reasons for this phenomenon, and he provides a critical analysis of the issues associated with political language. George Orwell represents some notable points from the essay to elucidate why "political writing is bad writing":

Lack of Clarity: Orwell emphasizes that political writing is often unclear and vague with writers using long, convoluted sentences and jargon that obfuscates meaning. This lack of clarity is intentional, as it allows politicians and propagandists to hide the truth and manipulate public opinion. Orwell contends that clarity of expression is essential for honest communication and clear thinking.

Dying Metaphors and Clichés: Orwell criticizes the overuse of metaphors and clichés in political writing, which he believes not only contributes to dull and lifeless prose but also obscures the writer's true intentions. He argues that when people rely on these tired, ready-made phrases, they are more likely to engage in lazy thinking and are less likely to convey their ideas effectively.

Pretentious Diction: Orwell criticizes the tendency of politicians and intellectuals to use overly complex and pretentious language to create an appearance of intelligence and authority. He suggests that this form of writing is often a cover for a lack of substantive content or genuine ideas. Orwell encourages writers to use simple, direct language to communicate effectively.

Euphemism and Deception: Orwell notes that political writing frequently employs euphemisms to soften harsh or uncomfortable truths. These euphemisms can obscure the reality of situations and manipulate public perception. He argues that writers should be more direct and honest in their language, even when discussing difficult or unpleasant topics.

Avoidance of Unpleasant Facts: Orwell points out that, political writers often evade discussing inconvenient facts, controversial issues, or difficult truths. Instead, they resort to distractions and diversions. He believes that good political writing should confront such facts and engage in open and honest debate.

Intentions behind Bad Writing: Orwell suggests that the bad writing in political discourse is often not accidental but is a deliberate strategy to manipulate the masses, create confusion, and maintain political power. By using obscure and convoluted language, those in power can control the narrative and suppress dissent.

In "Politics and the English Language," George Orwell argues that the quality of language and writing is intimately connected to the quality of thought and political discourse. He contends that writers and speakers should strive for clarity, honesty, and directness in their communication to ensure that political discussions and debates are both truthful and meaningful. In his view, the degradation of language in political discourse contributes to the degradation of democratic and intellectual discourse, and it is the responsibility of writers to resist this trend.

*****

👉 T. S. Eliot’s concept of the Impersonal theory of poetry

👉 Aristotle's Poetics | views on the plot of tragedy and its relative importance

👉 Poetry is the spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings | William Wordsworth

👉 Received Pronunciation (RP) | Distinctive features, criteria and major problems

👉 Speech mechanism | the functions of the various organs of speech

👉 Development of the English language | from the Anglo-Saxon to the Modern period